Skip to content

Criteria Corp reviews: what the assessment leaves open

In short

Criteria buyers praise ease of use and building their own assessments, and the complaint raised most is reporting and export limits (4 of the first 20 Capterra reviews). Three reviewers say the results add little beyond an interview. Tracy AI Interviewer interviews the person, follows up in their own field and keeps a recording, a timestamped transcript and what they said to each question. Your team decides.

What Criteria Corp reviews praise

Criteria Corp reviews are mostly positive. Buyers name ease of use for administrators and candidates, TestMaker for building their own assessments and an extra talent signal for managers, and Criteria says 4,000 customers trust it. It sells pre-employment assessments and video interviewing.

The complaints are about reporting, flexibility and what a result can tell you. A result shows performance on a set task; the step it leaves open is the conversation where the person explains their own work. Tracy AI Interviewer runs that conversation for each applicant, asks follow-ups in their own field, and keeps a recording and a timestamped transcript for a reviewer to check. How AI interviews work shows the steps.

What do the Criteria reviews cover?

The counts below come from the first 20 Capterra reviews, where Criteria shows 4.7 from 241 reviews (read 14 Nov 2026), dated June to November 2026. The first 10 of G2's 181 reviews are all marked incentivized by G2, so they are reported on their own. A review can raise more than one theme and 20 is a small sample, so read each count as a direction. Employee reviews of the company are not included.

What do buyers like about Criteria?

Ease of use comes first. Ten of the 20 Capterra reviews mention it in the pros, and an enterprise G2 reviewer (an incentivized review) wrote, "What I like best about Criteria is how easy the platform is to use for both administrators and candidates." A Talent Acquisition Operations Analyst liked "the customization options available through TestMaker, as we can create our own assessments according to our specific needs." A Talent Acquisition Manager said the aptitude assessments gave managers "an additional 'talent signal' to consider when evaluating candidates." Criteria says it is trusted by 4,000 customers.

What do buyers complain about?

Counts are out of the first 20 Capterra reviews, with one quote each. On G2's first 10 (all incentivized): reporting 2, flexibility 2, navigation or learning curve 2, and one review each for the rest.

Counts: our reading of the first 20 Capterra reviews, June to November 2026. A review can raise more than one theme. Quotes are word for word.

ComplaintReviews (of 20)One quoteSource
Reporting and export4"One significant drawback is the inability to view or export aggregate test scores for all candidates in one place."Capterra reviewer, Jun to Nov 2026
Flexibility to build or tailor assessments3"it would be nice to have more options to customize the assessments for specific roles."Capterra reviewer, Jun to Nov 2026
Results add little or need supervision3"I don't think it provides a whole lot of information to the Hiring Manager that isn't something we can find from a normal interview process."Capterra, Recruiter
Navigation, login and dashboard2"I found the dashboard a little hard to navigate"Capterra reviewer, Jun to Nov 2026
ATS integration2"Our biggest challenge was the Workday integration."Capterra reviewer, Jun to Nov 2026
Assessment length2"Some of the assessments can be quite long"Capterra reviewer, Jun to Nov 2026

Scroll the table sideways to see all 4 columns.

Bar chart of complaints in 20 Criteria Capterra reviews: reporting 4, flexibility 3, results add little 3, others 2.
Capterra reviews, of the first 20, that raise each complaint. A review can raise more than one. Capterra, first 20 of 241 reviews, June to November 2026, read on 14 Nov 2026.

Reporting and export is the theme Capterra reviewers raise most, 4 of 20; flexibility and results that add little follow with 3 each.

Why do some reviewers say the results are not enough?

Three Capterra reviewers question what a score tells a hiring team. One Talent Acquisition Manager wrote, "Candidates complete assessments with no accountability. Currently, I suspect a large number of candidates are using AI technologies to complete these tasks, making the results completely irrelevant." A recruiter wrote, "I don't think it provides a whole lot of information to the Hiring Manager that isn't something we can find from a normal interview process." A third said that for technical, field-based roles, hands-on experience "can be more valuable than performance on a standardized assessment."

Criteria's pricing page lists AI Proctoring, with image capture, screen and audio sampling and reports that flag activity for your team to review, and an AI Interview Agent for conversational screening, both as add-ons. Three of 20 is a small share, and whether the add-ons would have changed these reviewers' views is not stated.

If the third comment is your concern, the interview is the missing step: it records how someone explains their own work, where a result records how they performed.

Who is Criteria right for, and who is it not?

Criteria suits a team that wants validated aptitude, personality and skills assessments from one vendor, with video interviewing beside them, and that has someone to build assessments and handle reporting. It suits you less if you need aggregate exports without a spreadsheet, a deeper ATS connection without paying for more (Criteria lists premium integrations as an add-on), or an interview that shows how a person works through a technical problem. Criteria's packages are priced by request, so ask for each add-on in writing.

Sample interview: Tracy asks how a database migration was run, then what happened when it failed halfway.
A recreated Tracy interview: the follow-up at 04:49 asks what happened when a migration failed halfway. Illustration with sample data

Tracy asks about the detail the candidate left out, and the answer is timestamped.

What Tracy adds to Criteria's assessments

  1. Every applicant starts on click, at any hour, with no scheduling and no recruiter on the call, so the interview reaches the whole pool.
  2. Tracy asks the next question in the applicant's own field and waits for the answer, so a reviewer sees how the person reasons.
  3. Every result keeps a recording, a timestamped transcript and a written assessment per question with its reasoning, for your team to check.
Four steps: share a link, Tracy follows up, read the record, you decide.
Tracy runs the interview and keeps the record, so your team reads how a person reasons beside the assessment result. Illustration, no data.

The interview adds how a person reasons to what an assessment shows.

How does Tracy answer the complaints that matter here?

The complaints that matter to a technical volume-hiring team, set against what Tracy does and what it does not fix. Counts: first 20 Capterra reviews. Tracy column: Tracy's published capabilities.

Complaint raised in reviewsWhat Tracy doesWhat Tracy does not fix
Results add little (3)Follow-ups in the person's own field, and a recording, a timestamped transcript and what the person said to each question.Tracy has no validated aptitude or personality test, and does not score, rank or reject.
Needs supervision, AI use (1 of the 3)A video interview with integrity signals, such as tab changes and gaze, shown with their evidence to a person.A signal is never proof. A person decides.
Reporting and export (4)A report per interview, plus API and MCP access for your own tools.Bulk export of results is not stated on the pages reviewed; ask in the demo.
ATS integration (2)Workable and Breezy HR beside the ATS connector, plus API and MCP.A Workday connector is not stated on the Connect page. Greenhouse has a guide with a Book a demo button, and no write-back is stated.
Assessment length (2)The interview follows your brief; an interview is billed per started 20 minutes.The applicant still gives the time an interview takes.

What does Criteria cost, in brief?

Criteria's pricing page lists three packages, Assess, Interview and Hire, each with "Request Pricing", and separate upgrades for AI Proctoring, AI Features, the AI Interview Agent and premium integrations. Tracy's price is public: $1 per credit, one credit for each started 20 minutes, the first 3 results free, no seats and no upfront cost. At 20 minutes each, 100 interviews cost $100. See the pricing page and what an AI interview costs.

When to use Criteria and when to add Tracy

Stay with Criteria if a validated assessment battery with video interviewing is what you want and your team can live with the reporting limits above. Add Tracy if the first round has to show how a person reasons, with a recording a reviewer can check. Criteria's tests measure performance on set tasks; Tracy's interview records how someone explains their own work. See Tracy vs TestGorilla and iMocha alternatives for another view, and AI technical interviews for the method. Teams that screen at volume can start from hiring at volume.

Common questions

Is Criteria Corp good, according to reviews?
Reviewers praise ease of use; the summary and the counts above have the detail, read 14 Nov 2026.
What are the main complaints about Criteria?
Reporting and export comes first on Capterra at 4 of 20; the table above lists the rest.
Are Criteria's G2 reviews reliable?
All 10 reviews on the first G2 page we read carry G2's incentivized label, so this page counts them apart.
How much does Criteria cost?
Criteria's packages are priced by request; the cost section above has the detail.
Does Criteria offer interviews?
Yes. Its pages list async and real-time video interviewing and an AI scoring add-on, and its pricing page lists an AI Interview Agent add-on.
How is a Tracy interview different from an assessment?
Tracy interviews the person and follows up in their own field, then gives a reviewer a recording, a transcript and what was said to each question; a person decides.

Run one role through Tracy

Create one interview for a technical role, read the recording and report, and compare the follow-ups with your assessment results. First 3 results free.

Book a demo (opens in a new tab) Try it free (opens in a new tab)

Your first 3 results are free. No card needed.

Sources