In short
Otter.ai buyers praise it for notes and transcripts on calls they hold, and accuracy is the most common complaint among the nine G2 reviews read. None describes interviewing candidates. Tracy AI Interviewer runs the interview itself, asks follow-ups in the applicant's own field and leaves a recording, a timestamped transcript and a written assessment per question. Your team reads the evidence and decides.
Otter.ai reviews are positive and mostly about convenience. G2 shows 4.4 out of 5 from 550 reviews. The sample read here is the first nine reviews G2 served on page 1, dated 5 September to 14 November 2026; themes are counted by us, and a review can raise more than one. What the nine do not describe is interviewing candidates. Otter.ai makes a finished call searchable, which leaves the call itself, and the second question in it, to a person. For first-round hiring, Tracy AI Interviewer asks that second question in the person's own field.
Choose Otter.ai when your people run the calls and you want a transcript and summary of each.
Choose Tracy when the first round should reach every applicant, with evidence a reviewer can check.

Otter.ai takes the notes on a call you hold; Tracy runs the interview when nobody is on the call.
What do buyers praise about Otter.ai?
Seven of the nine praise the same thing: they can follow the meeting without taking notes. A founder at a staffing firm wrote that Otter lets them stay present in long meetings (G2, November 2026). A software test engineer said live captions and transcripts helped with accents on international calls. A founder says it captures conversations, identifies speakers and writes summaries with action items; an intern likes the clean interface and quick transcripts. Four praise how it fits with meeting tools such as Meet, Teams and Zoom, three praise speaker identification and two like AI Chat. A talent specialist put the limit on it kindly: "if you are a casual user then you will love" it (G2, October 2026). Every one of these is about a call a person already holds. Running the interview itself is the gap Tracy fills.
What do buyers complain about?
Accuracy comes first: six of the nine say transcripts or summaries slip with accents, background noise, overlapping speakers or technical terms. A customer success assistant wrote that the transcription "isn't always completely accurate" (G2, October 2026). Four say notes or summaries miss detail and need review before use.
Four name the free plan's limits. Otter's pricing page bears that out: Basic includes 300 transcription minutes a month and 30 minutes per conversation, and Pro 1,200 minutes and 90 minutes.
Three call transcript editing or speaker tools clunky. A senior correspondent says speaker identification can get stuck on a second appearance of a voice with little audio and cannot be cut short by assigning the speaker manually (G2, November 2026). Another says long transcripts are clunky to navigate and edit, and a third would like managing many transcripts across folders to be more intuitive.
One reviewer dislikes the default of asking to auto-join every video call, and one says notifications still appear when turned off.

Accuracy leads the complaints in the first nine Otter.ai reviews G2 served.
What do the reviews not say?
None of the nine reviews mentions interviewing candidates, applicant tracking systems, follow-up questions or a recording a hiring manager could replay beside the transcript. Two reviewers work in recruiting, a founder at a staffing firm and a talent specialist, and neither says what Otter is for in their work. The founder mentions only the auto-join default.
The reviews show a tool people like for catching what was said in meetings they attend. They say little about running a first-round interview at volume, because that is not the job the tool describes. Otter's own pages name sales, education and media, and a hiring use case is not stated on the pricing page.
Which complaints would cost an interviewing team most?
Accuracy matters most when the exact wording is the evidence. Six of the nine reviews raise it and four say summaries miss detail. In a meeting a slipped word costs a re-read. In an interview it can change what a candidate appears to have said, so a reviewer needs the transcript beside the recording, not the summary alone.
Length is the second problem. Four reviewers name the free plan's limits, and Basic caps a conversation at 30 minutes, which is shorter than many first-round interviews. Volume is the third: 100 interviews of 20 minutes is about 33 hours of calls that people still hold, and 1,000 is about 333 hours (our arithmetic). A notetaker saves the typing, not those hours. In one customer's result, time to hire fell from 44 days to 7 and Tracy handled the work of 53 full-time recruiters in one month.
The three transcript-editing complaints matter least for a single interview and most for a team that reviews dozens a week. A fair test for your own team is to ask who catches a wrong line, then count the minutes a reviewer spends checking a transcript against the audio and set that against the minutes the notetaker saved.
Who is Otter.ai for, and who is it not for?
Otter suits people who attend many meetings and want a record without typing: students, journalists, sales teams. Its own use-case pages name sales, education and media. It suits a recruiter who runs every interview personally and wants a transcript to review afterwards, on Pro at $8.33 per user per month on annual billing.
It suits a volume hiring team less. A notetaker records calls a person holds, so the number of interviews is still the number of hours your people have, and no review mentions an applicant tracking system. As reviewers note, notes need review and editing before use.
For a team that screens in several languages or feeds an applicant tracking system, check the plan limits and integrations against your own list before you buy.
What Tracy adds to interview notes
01 Reach every applicant
Each applicant starts on click, at any hour, with no scheduling and no recruiter on the call. The number of interviews stops depending on the hours your people have.
02 Ask the next question
Tracy asks in the applicant's own field, follows what they said and waits for the answer. A thin answer gets its follow-up in the interview, not in the notes afterwards.
03 Keep the evidence
Each interview leaves a recording of both sides, a timestamped transcript and a written assessment per question with its reasoning. A reviewer finds the words in the transcript and checks them against the recording, and a person decides.
If a result is thin, the reviewer can open the transcript and recording and decide whether to run a follow-up interview.

A thin answer gets a follow-up inside the interview, and the transcript keeps both.
Otter.ai pricing in brief
Otter lists Basic at $0, Pro at $8.33 per user per month on annual billing ($16.99 monthly) and Business at $19.99 on annual billing. The limits matter for interviews: Basic caps a conversation at 30 minutes and Pro at 90, so a 45-minute interview is over Basic's cap (our arithmetic). Minutes are per user and do not roll over. Tracy charges $1 per credit, one credit per started 20 minutes, with the first 3 results free and no seats. The Otter.ai pricing page works through both at 100, 500 and 1,000 interviews.
Which path fits you?
- Weighing both side by side: Tracy vs Otter.ai.
- Looking for other notetakers: Otter.ai alternatives and Fireflies.ai alternatives.
- Hiring in waves: volume hiring.
- The report a reviewer gets: AI interview reports.
Common questions
What do Otter.ai reviews say?
What are the main Otter.ai complaints?
Does Otter.ai work with an applicant tracking system?
Is Otter.ai good for interviewing candidates?
Read the evidence behind one interview
Run one interview and read the recording, the timestamped transcript and what each person said. The first 3 results are free.
Book a demo (opens in a new tab) Try it free (opens in a new tab)
Your first 3 results are free. No card needed.
Sources
- G2, Otter.ai reviews, retrieved 14 Nov 2026.
- Otter.ai, Pricing, retrieved 14 Nov 2026.
- Tracy AI Interviewer, Pricing, retrieved 14 Nov 2026.
- Tracy AI Interviewer, Connect, retrieved 14 Nov 2026.



