Skip to content

Karat reviews, and a first round that starts on click

In short

Karat's G2 reviewers praise the engineer time it frees and its scheduling, and four of nine worry about the candidate experience of outside interviewers. Tracy AI Interviewer adds an interview every engineer can start on click, with follow-ups in their own field and a recording and timestamped transcript behind each result. Choose Karat for live, human-led interviews. Your team decides either way.

Karat reviews here cover the technical interviewing company at karat.com, not the jewellery retailers, card issuers or rewards apps that share the name. Karat gives your engineers their hours back by sending outside engineers to interview live, while Tracy takes the interviewer out of round one altogether.

Karat's G2 reviews are mostly positive, and the nine read are all from 2023: reviewers praise the engineer time Karat frees and its scheduling, and the recurring worry is the candidate's side of an interview run by outside engineers. Tracy AI Interviewer runs the interview with AI instead of an outside engineer.

Choose Karat when:

  • you want live, human-led interviews run for you by certified interview engineers
  • you want the scoring rubrics Karat says its trained interviewers apply
  • your engineers' calendars are the bottleneck

Choose Tracy when:

  • each interview should start on click, at any hour, with no outside interviewer to schedule
  • every applicant should get follow-ups on approach and trade-offs in their own field
  • a reviewer needs a recording and a transcript to check each result
Three steps: live Karat engineers, a Tracy interview on click, and your team deciding from the evidence.
Who runs the first round with each option. Illustration, no data.

Karat's engineers run round one live; Tracy runs it on click; your team reads the evidence and decides.

What do reviewers like about Karat?

Counts are out of the nine G2 reviews, with one quote each.

G2 reviews of Karat. Quotes are word for word.

ThemeReviews (of 9)One quoteReviewer and date
Frees engineer time3 (reviews 2, 5 and 1)"...a little more time on their calendars by not having to administer assessments themselves."Technical Recruiter, May 2023
Flexible scheduling3"Provides a lot of flexibility in scheduling interviews for the best time for candidates."Enterprise reviewer, May 2023
Fast feedback2"Easy to setup and send to candidates. Feedback within 24 hours."Mid-market reviewer, Jun 2023

Scroll the table sideways to see all 4 columns.

What do reviewers say could be better?

The reviews raise no theme about follow-up questions on a candidate's own answer, which is the gap Tracy fills. Counts below are out of the same nine reviews. One reviewer named no concern.

G2 reviews of Karat. Quotes are word for word.

ThemeReviews (of 9)One quoteReviewer and date
Candidate experience4"...do not gain any insight into the company or team they are applying for."Enterprise reviewer, May 2023
Hard or fast-paced questions2"Questions are designed to prioritize speed over optimization."Enterprise reviewer, May 2023
Roles not yet covered1"We have some roles that Karat does not have interviewers or interviews prepared to do."Enterprise reviewer, May 2023
Calibration of a new assessment1"...the calibration process in the beginning with a new assessment can feel a bit daunting."Technical Recruiter, May 2023
Analytics export1"...not an option to export data to Excel files directly from their website"Mid-market reviewer, May 2023

Scroll the table sideways to see all 4 columns.

Bar chart of nine Karat G2 reviews: candidate experience 4, hard questions 2, roles, calibration and export 1 each.
Concerns raised in nine G2 reviews of Karat. Nine is a small sample and the reviews were first written in 2023. G2, nine reviews of Karat, read 14 Nov 2026.

Candidate experience is the concern raised most often in nine G2 reviews of Karat, followed by question difficulty.

Where do the Karat review counts come from?

The nine reviews counted are G2 reviews of Karat's interviewing service, first submitted between May and August 2023, six of them labelled as collected through a G2 invitation. G2 lists 12 reviews at 4.2 out of 5: six five-star, five four-star and one two-star. The first page gave 10 reviews; one is about a different product called Karat and is not counted. The two reviews beyond that page were not read, so their dates and themes are not in the counts. TrustRadius shows a 7 out of 10 score and no written reviews. A review can raise several themes, and nine is a small sample.

What do the Karat reviews mean for a buyer?

Praise centres on what Karat takes off the hiring team: interviewer time and scheduling. The recurring worry is the candidate's side. When outside engineers run the interview, candidates meet nobody from the team, and four reviewers said so in different words.

One reviewer gave 1.5 stars and told readers to train their own team on live coding assessments instead (Mid-market, Jun 2023, updated May 2025). It is one voice among nine and the reviews are from 2023. Karat's pages now also list an AI Readiness offer, so ask for recent references from a team like yours before you decide.

Where does Karat win?

Karat's interviews are live and human-led, run by certified interview engineers on the buyer's behalf and available 24/7. Karat says its interviewers score against consistent rubrics and that it covers over 100 technical languages and frameworks. A human can react to a surprising answer in the moment, and your engineers never run a screen. Karat's coding environment and report format are not described on the pages reviewed, so ask for a demo. Security and compliance terms, accessibility and contract terms are not verified for Karat on the pages reviewed either, so put them to its team.

Tracy does not put a person in the room. If a live engineer across the table is what you are buying, Karat is the closer fit, and Tracy vs Karat sets the two side by side.

Which review themes does a Tracy interview answer?

Take the concern raised most often: four of nine reviewers say candidates meet outside interviewers and learn nothing about the team (Enterprise reviewer, May 2023). A candidate in a Tracy interview meets no person either, so the fair test is what the candidate is told and asked. They open a browser link with no account, hear on the join screen that the conversation is recorded and transcribed, and get follow-ups in their own field. Candidates rate the experience 92 on NPS.

The praised themes line up too. Engineer time freed and flexible scheduling are three reviews each, and a Tracy interview needs no engineer on the call and no booked slot. If candidates need to hear from your team before they decide, plan that conversation after the first round.

What Tracy adds to a technical first round

01 Reach every engineer

Each engineer can start on click, at any hour, with no scheduling and no outside interviewer. No engineer's calendar is booked, and the whole pool gets the same first round.

02 Ask the next question

Tracy reads the CV when the CV check is on, asks in the engineer's own field, waits for the end of the thought and asks for the missing detail. A coding task can sit inside the same interview, with follow-ups on approach and trade-offs.

03 Keep the evidence

Every result comes with a recording, a timestamped transcript and a written assessment per question with its reasoning. A person decides; Tracy does not score, rank or reject anyone.

Role coverage is a setup step: describe the role and Tracy drafts the questions, which you edit or replace with your own.

Sample interview: Tracy asks how a queue is bounded, the engineer answers, Tracy asks about the trade-off.
Tracy follows up on the trade-off in a fictional engineer's answer, so the reviewer reads the reasoning. Illustration with sample content.

The follow-up asks for the trade-off behind the engineer's choice, so the transcript shows how they reason.

What does Karat cost, in brief?

Karat states no price on the pages reviewed: Request a Consult and Request a Demo lead to one page. Tracy's price is public: the first 3 results are free, then $1 per credit, one credit per started 20 minutes, with no seats and no upfront cost. Enterprise is priced to your volume. To compare, run one role you hire for now in Tracy.

What are the alternatives to Karat?

Stay with Karat if live human interviewers and your engineers' time are what you are buying. Look at Tracy if you screen engineers at volume (the pricing page has worked examples) and want every applicant interviewed at any hour, with follow-ups and evidence. The Karat alternatives page lists the wider field, Tracy for technical interviews shows how a technical screen runs, and coding interview follow-up questions gives examples of the follow-ups Tracy asks.

Common questions

Are Karat reviews good?
On the numbers, yes: 4.2 out of 5 from 12 G2 reviews, six of them five-star. The nine read were all first written in 2023, two were not read, and TrustRadius shows no written reviews.
What do people dislike about Karat?
On G2, four of nine reviewers raise the candidate experience of outside interviewers and two say questions are hard or fast-paced. One each mention roles Karat has not covered, the calibration of a new assessment and analytics export.
Are Karat interviews run by people or by AI?
By people: Karat describes live, human-led interviews run by certified interview engineers on the buyer's behalf. Its AI Readiness offer is described as a way to evaluate the AI-enabled engineer.
Does Karat publish a price?
Not on the pages reviewed. Request a Consult and Request a Demo go to one page.
Are there Karat reviews on Reddit or Glassdoor?
This page reads G2 only, with a TrustRadius check. Employee reviews on Glassdoor and similar sites describe working at Karat, which is a different question.
When is Tracy the better choice than Karat?
When each interview should start on click at any hour and every applicant should get follow-ups in their field, with a recording and transcript to check. Choose Karat for live, human-led interviews.

Run one engineering role in Tracy

Set up one role and see what the candidate is asked and what the reviewer receives. The first 3 results are free.

Book a demo (opens in a new tab) Try it free (opens in a new tab)

Your first 3 results are free. No card needed.

Sources