In short
Teamtailor reviewers praise ease of use (15 of the 25 Capterra reviews read) and raise reporting most as a gap (7 of 25). Tracy AI Interviewer leaves reporting alone and adds the first-round interview, which follows up in the person's own field and leaves a recording and transcript. Teamtailor stays the system of record, and your team decides who moves on.
Teamtailor reviews on Capterra put reporting first among the complaints: of the 25 listed first, seven say reporting or analytics is thin and four mention calendar, scheduling or sync problems. Reviewers also praise Teamtailor, mostly for ease. Few of them write about the first-round interview itself, and that is the part Tracy AI Interviewer covers: it asks follow-ups in the person's own field and keeps a recording, a timestamped transcript and what the person said to each question behind every result.
What do buyers praise in Teamtailor reviews?
Ease comes first: 15 of the 25 reviews call Teamtailor easy, intuitive, user-friendly or simple to use. A hiring manager wrote that it is "easy to use, intuitive and fun" (Capterra, February 2025). Two reviewers name value or price as a reason to like it; an HR director wrote "Great product, great price and the usability is TOP!" (Capterra, November 2020). Support is praised too: "The customer service is excellent" (Capterra, August 2021), and G2 counts customer support second (40).
Teamtailor is an applicant tracking system, and these are the things an ATS is praised for. The reviews say little about what happens in the first conversation with an applicant.
What do the Teamtailor reviews cover?
Capterra showed 4.5 from 114 reviews on 14 November 2026. The counts below cover the 25 listed first under "most helpful", dated 2018 to November 2026 (seven from March 2026 on), with themes coded by hand; a review can carry more than one theme, so read each count as a direction. Of the 25, 16 give 5 stars, six give 4, two give 3 and one gives 0.5. G2 showed 4.6 from 584 reviews; its own topic counts put ease of use first (44) and limited customization first among drawbacks (12).
What do buyers complain about?
Counts are out of the 25 Capterra reviews, with one quote each. A review can raise more than one issue.

Among the 25 reviews read, reporting is raised most, 7, ahead of customising, calendar sync and bugs.
Capterra, the 25 reviews of Teamtailor listed first under most helpful, 2018 to Nov 2026, read 14 Nov 2026. Reviewers are cited by role and date.
| Complaint | Reviews of 25 | What a reviewer wrote |
|---|---|---|
| Reporting or analytics | 7 | "Reporting needs to be upscaled to meet stakeholders needs" (HR advisor, March 2026) |
| Customising or complex workflows | 5 | "Customisation options for workflows, permissions, and deeper analytics may require additional effort or workarounds." (Education consultant, June 2026) |
| Calendar, scheduling or sync | 4 | "i still have problems with syncing to outlook and jobboards." (Project Manager, March 2026) |
| Bugs, stability or support | 4 | "It's quite buggy" (Sales Manager, November 2026) |
| Price | 1 | "Excellent for SMBs, Pricey for Scaling Teams" (recruiter, July 2026) |
What do the recent reviews say?
Four of the seven reviews from March to November 2026 raise reporting or analytics, against three of the 18 dated before 2026. The lowest score in the set, 0.5 in November 2026, is about bugs, permissions and support: "I cannot edit any templates unless I am an admin..." On G2 the first review, from a mid-market team in August 2026, asks for "more flexibility when creating and customizing reports", and Teamtailor replied that the feedback on reporting, Gmail and Google Chat is "particularly useful". G2 flags that review as written by a business partner of the seller or a competitor and leaves it out of its scores.
What do reviewers say about interviews?
Three of the 25 reviews touch the interview itself. A recruiter lists "Basic Interview Scheduling & Calendar Syncing" among the cons (July 2026), an operations manager wants a better "Hosting system of group interviews" (March 2025), and an HR reviewer likes "the video platform with the interview booking" (April 2025). Teamtailor's own pages describe interview kits that the hiring team rates, and AI that summarises video meetings and CVs. A candidate-facing AI interview is not stated on the pages reviewed.
Three of 25 reviews touch the interview, against seven for reporting. Tracy does not change reporting, or sync with Outlook and job boards. The one theme it speaks to is scheduling: four reviews mention calendar, scheduling or sync problems, and an interview that starts on click needs no calendar slot.
What does Teamtailor say about itself?
Teamtailor shows 4.6/5 on its own home page and calls itself the ATS behind great hiring. Its pricing page is a quote request that lists unlimited users and job postings, over 250 features and 550+ integrations with an open API, and it says it is fully certified with ISO 27001, ISO 27701 and ISO 42001. Its interview kits hold instructions, questions and a scorecard that the hiring team rates, and its AI summarises CVs and video interviews and, Teamtailor says, can assess candidates against your criteria.
Who is Teamtailor right for, and who is it not?
Teamtailor is right for teams that want one system for postings, career site, talent pools and automation, and an interface hiring managers pick up quickly. It fits less well where reviewers say they need deeper reporting, more customising or tighter scheduling and sync. Teamtailor's pages describe AI that summarises, recommends questions and, it says, assesses candidates against your criteria, built around a person running the interview; a candidate-facing AI interview is not stated. Tracy sits beside it for that.
Which path fits you:
- Technical roles: technical interviews.
- Hundreds of applicants: volume hiring.
- Price and head-to-head: Teamtailor pricing and Tracy vs Teamtailor.
Where does Tracy fit beside Teamtailor?
Tracy does not replace Teamtailor's reporting or its calendar and job board sync. It covers the interview itself:
- Evidence per interview: a recording of both sides, a timestamped transcript and what the person said to each question. A person decides.
- Your own questions: bring them, or describe the role and Tracy drafts them for you to edit. Enterprise setup is customised to your workflow.
Candidates rate Tracy 92 on NPS. Run one role through Tracy and compare the reports.
What Tracy adds beside Teamtailor
- Take scheduling out of the first round. Each applicant starts on click, at any hour, with no calendar slot and no recruiter on the call. A hundred applicants do not need a hundred bookings.
- Ask the next question. Tracy follows the answer in the person's own field and waits. A polished headline meets a specific follow-up.
- Keep the evidence. Every result has a recording, a timestamped transcript and a written assessment per question with its reasoning. Your team reviews it and decides.

Reporting stays with Teamtailor; the first round gains reach, follow-ups and evidence.

Every point in a Tracy result links to the applicant's own words and a time in the recording.
What does Teamtailor cost, in brief?
Teamtailor publishes no price: its pricing page is a quote request. See Teamtailor pricing for what the page says and what to ask. Tracy's price is on her pricing page: $1 per credit, one credit per started 20 minutes, the first 3 results free.
What should you test before you buy?
Reviews point to five things to test before you sign, and each one fits in a demo or a trial week:
- Reporting: ask Teamtailor to build the report your stakeholders want, not a standard one.
- Calendar and sync: connect your own calendar and job boards and book a real interview.
- Permissions: log in as a hiring manager and try to edit a template.
- Support: ask for the response times in writing, and ask a reference customer how a fault was handled.
- Interviews: ask what happens when a candidate should be interviewed without a person on the call, and what that costs.
For the fifth, Tracy runs the interview itself, so one role is enough to compare.
Common questions
Is Teamtailor good?
What are the most common Teamtailor complaints?
Does Teamtailor have an AI interviewer?
Can Tracy run beside Teamtailor?
Compare one role's first-round report
Read the recording and report next to your Teamtailor process. The first 3 results are free.
Book a demo (opens in a new tab) Try it free (opens in a new tab)
Your first 3 results are free. No card needed.
Sources
- Teamtailor reviews, Capterra, retrieved 14 Nov 2026.
- Teamtailor reviews, G2, retrieved 14 Nov 2026.
- Teamtailor, Pricing, retrieved 14 Nov 2026.
- Tracy AI Interviewer, Pricing, retrieved 11 Nov 2026.



